Current:Home > StocksSupreme Court kills Biden's student debt plan in a setback for millions of borrowers-LoTradeCoin
Supreme Court kills Biden's student debt plan in a setback for millions of borrowers
View Date:2024-12-24 00:04:47
Follow NPR's live coverage for the latest updates and reaction to this opinion.
In a highly anticipated decision, the Supreme Court on Friday struck down President Biden's groundbreaking plan to forgive some or all federal student loan debt for tens of millions of Americans.
By a 6-to-3 vote on ideological lines, the high court ruled that federal law does not authorize the Department of Education to cancel such student loan debt.
Writing for the majority, Chief Justice John Roberts said: "The authority to 'modify' statutes and regulations allows the Secretary to make modest adjustments and additions to existing provisions, not transform them."
Siding with the states, Justice Amy Coney Barrett said, in her concurring opinion, said the major questions doctrine "reinforces" the majority's conclusion "but is not necessary to it."
In her dissent, Justice Elena Kagan criticized the court's "overreach, and noted she would have decided the states didn't have the right to sue.
"The plaintiffs in this case are six States that have no personal stake in the Secretary' loan forgiveness plan," she said. "They are classic ideological plaintiffs: They think the plan a very bad idea, but they are no worse off because the Secretary differs."
Last August, President Biden told federal student loan borrowers that the U.S. government would cancel up to $20,000 of debt for low income students who had received a Pell Grant to attend college, and up to $10,000 for the vast majority of remaining borrowers. He cited a 2001 law that allows the Secretary of Education "to alleviate the hardship that federal student loan recipients may suffer as a result of national emergencies." That is the same law that President Trump used to freeze federal student loan payments and interest accrual due to the COVID pandemic.
Soon after Biden's announcement, however, six states filed a lawsuit to stop the implementation of the debt cancellation plan, arguing that Biden exceeded his authority under the federal law. The Supreme Court ultimately stepped in to review the case.
The high court's ruling signifies another example of its expanding use of the "Major Questions Doctrine," the idea that Congress must speak very clearly when granting power to executive agencies like the Department of Education to make decisions about issues that are politically or economically significant. And, as the doctrine says, if there is any ambiguity to whether Congress has granted this power, courts should not presume that Congress did so. Last year, the high court struck down the Secretary of Labor's vaccine mandate on these grounds.
The decision comes as a disappointment to federal student loan borrowers who were eligible for relief under the plan — as many as 43 million borrowers, or roughly 1 in 8 Americans.
Come fall, student loan interest accrual and payments will begin again, affecting borrowers in all 50 states.
veryGood! (73)
Related
- Texas now tops in SEC? Miami in trouble? Five overreactions to college football Week 11
- Blake Lively’s Sister Robyn Reacts to Comment About “Negative Voices” Amid Online Criticism
- What to know about the heavy exchange of fire between Israel and Lebanon’s Hezbollah
- Blake Lively Celebrates Birthday With Taylor Swift and More Stars at Singer's Home
- Pete Rose fans say final goodbye at 14-hour visitation in Cincinnati
- AEW All In 2024: Live results, match grades, card, highlights for London PPV
- Lydia Ko completes ‘Cinderella-like story’ by winning Women’s British Open soon after Olympic gold
- 'I never seen a slide of this magnitude': Alaska landslide kills 1, at least 3 injured
- Klay Thompson returns to Golden State in NBA Cup game. How to watch
- Closings set in trial of ex-politician accused of killing Las Vegas investigative reporter
Ranking
- Powell says Fed will likely cut rates cautiously given persistent inflation pressures
- US expands area in Mexico to apply for border asylum appointments, hoping to slow push north
- Watch live: NASA set to reveal how Boeing Starliner astronauts will return to Earth
- NFL preseason winners, losers: Trey Lance remains a puzzle for Cowboys
- What that 'Disclaimer' twist says about the misogyny in all of us
- Massachusetts towns warn about rare, lethal mosquito-borne virus: 'Take extra precautions'
- Police investigate deaths of 5 people in New York City suburb
- Below Deck Mediterranean's Chef Serves Potentially Deadly Meal to Allergic Guest—and Sandy Is Pissed
Recommendation
-
Two 'incredibly rare' sea serpents seen in Southern California waters months apart
-
8 wounded in shootout involving police and several people in Pennsylvania
-
Girl, 11, dies after vehicle crashes into tree in California. 5 other young teens were injured
-
Why Brian Austin Green and Tori Spelling Didn't Speak for 18 Years
-
1 monkey captured, 42 monkeys still on the loose after escaping research facility in SC
-
Ohio prison holds first-ever five-course meal open to public on facility grounds
-
Utah judge to decide if author of children’s book on grief will face trial in her husband’s death
-
Foo Fighters will donate to Kamala Harris after Trump used their song 'My Hero'